| Revision as of 21:43, 27 May 2012 editMontanabw (talk | contribs)Autopatrolled, Event coordinators, Extended confirmed users, Page movers, File movers, New page reviewers, Pending changes reviewers, Rollbackers105,500 edits →What is and what is not horse tack, what method do you use to decide what goes in this category?: take it to WPEQ← Previous edit | Revision as of 12:55, 28 May 2012 edit undoSamuraiantiqueworld (talk | contribs)Extended confirmed users3,886 edits →What is and what is not horse tack, what method do you use to decide what goes in this category?: look at your own actions some timeNext edit → | ||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
| :Books on horse tack and equipment abound. You can easily purchase one. As for feedbags, bandages, etc., you make a valid point that there is a place for some rethinking of the horse tack categories, as the line between "tack" (saddles, bridles, harnesses, training gear and the things attached to the same) and equipment (protective boots, stable gear, etc.) is a fine and often fuzzy one and you can actually find different books with different definitions. But running around and unilaterally changing things is not the way to fix it, neither is arguing with me and personalizing the discussion. Take it to WikiProject Equine and let the whole group discuss the issue. ]<sup>]</sup> 21:43, 27 May 2012 (UTC) | :Books on horse tack and equipment abound. You can easily purchase one. As for feedbags, bandages, etc., you make a valid point that there is a place for some rethinking of the horse tack categories, as the line between "tack" (saddles, bridles, harnesses, training gear and the things attached to the same) and equipment (protective boots, stable gear, etc.) is a fine and often fuzzy one and you can actually find different books with different definitions. But running around and unilaterally changing things is not the way to fix it, neither is arguing with me and personalizing the discussion. Take it to WikiProject Equine and let the whole group discuss the issue. ]<sup>]</sup> 21:43, 27 May 2012 (UTC) | ||
| *So what book did you refer to when you decided that horseshoes were no longer considered to be horse tack? Were are your discussions with WikiProject Equine on whether horseshoes are or are no horse tack and it was YOU that UNILATERALLY decided that horseshoes were no longer considered to be horse tack without any discussion not me, I did not remove ANY items from the horse tack category, I just made some new sub categories. If you remove one non horse tack item then remove all non horse tack items. Start a new category such as "Horse related equipment" etc and put protective equipment, horseshoes, horse tack etc in the new category before I do it. ] (]) 12:55, 28 May 2012 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 12:55, 28 May 2012
 | Equine Category‑class | ||||||
| |||||||
What is and what is not horse tack, what method do you use to decide what goes in this category?
Since January 2nd 2008 Horseshoes had been listed in the horse tack category, suddenly an editor who had edited this category for quite some time decided that Horseshoes is not horse tack after all and removed it, members of the WikiProject Equine have also edited the same category with out realizing that Horseshoes was in the wrong category, which brings into question several other suspect articles that are in Category:Horse tack such as Voss v. Fisher, is this horse tack, is a Feedbag horse tack, how about Stable bandage, is this really horse tack, should there be a category for horse related equipment that is not actually horse tack, maybe its time to scrutinize ALL of the articles and re-categorize the articles that really are not horse tack into some other category so that people who use Misplaced Pages do not get false information, just a thought.Samuraiantiqueworld (talk) 07:29, 24 May 2012 (UTC)
- Books on horse tack and equipment abound. You can easily purchase one. As for feedbags, bandages, etc., you make a valid point that there is a place for some rethinking of the horse tack categories, as the line between "tack" (saddles, bridles, harnesses, training gear and the things attached to the same) and equipment (protective boots, stable gear, etc.) is a fine and often fuzzy one and you can actually find different books with different definitions. But running around and unilaterally changing things is not the way to fix it, neither is arguing with me and personalizing the discussion. Take it to WikiProject Equine and let the whole group discuss the issue. Montanabw 21:43, 27 May 2012 (UTC)
- So what book did you refer to when you decided that horseshoes were no longer considered to be horse tack? Were are your discussions with WikiProject Equine on whether horseshoes are or are no horse tack and it was YOU that UNILATERALLY decided that horseshoes were no longer considered to be horse tack without any discussion not me, I did not remove ANY items from the horse tack category, I just made some new sub categories. If you remove one non horse tack item then remove all non horse tack items. Start a new category such as "Horse related equipment" etc and put protective equipment, horseshoes, horse tack etc in the new category before I do it. Samuraiantiqueworld (talk) 12:55, 28 May 2012 (UTC)