| Revision as of 00:09, 22 May 2005 editJuliusThyssen (talk | contribs)124 editsNo edit summary← Previous edit | Latest revision as of 01:57, 27 September 2022 edit undoMalnadachBot (talk | contribs)11,637,095 editsm Removed stale messages from inactive IP talkpage. (Task 13)Tag: AWB | ||
| (5 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| {{Blanked IP talk}} | |||
| I have redirected your ] to a pre-existing article. ] 00:05, 28 Dec 2003 (UTC) | |||
| Hi, I just wanted to comment on some of the changes you made to the ] page. Some I agree with, and you seem to be knowledgeable particularly with dates - changing the dates to the release dates rather than the dates I used, which was when they charted, is more correct. I don't understand all the choices for deletion - some of the songs like the ABBA and Roxy Music ones, yes they are borderline. Not strictly disco, but containing elements of it, which is why I included them, but if you think they should not be there, I tend to agree. But some of the others .. Diana Ross's "Upside Down" and "My Old Piano" deleted while "I'm Coming Out" from the same album, writer and producer left on the list? And all of the Chic and Sister Sledge songs (same writer/producers/sound) still there. The songs are virtually identical. Likewise Boney M - I don't think they even recorded a song that wasn't disco, their entire catalogue could justifiably be on the list. Andy Gibb - "Shadow Dancing" and "An Everlasting Love" are more disco than many of the songs on the list but they've been deleted. The other two Gibb songs, were borderline as per my earlier comment. Other songs such as Yvonne Elliman's "Love Me" and Samantha Sang's "Emotion" I do think are indicative of the disco era - they might be slow disco, but they have exactly the same beats and instrumentation, it's only the tempo that differs. Just interested in your opinion. I believe several of the songs you deleted should be reinstated, but I'd just like to understand and agree upon what the criteria should be for inclusion on or exlusion from the list. | |||
| Regards ] 14:04 21 May 2004 (UTC) | |||
| Your claim for some tracks being "Hi-NRG" is weird, since it didn't exist as a musical genre at the time of most of the tracks you erased from the list. Hey, I was there when it hit the charts ;-) and I'm pretty sure they were "disco". I'd say anything between 110 and 135 BPM falls under the disco category as long as it's from that time and place and has the ingredients. ] | |||
| ==Welcome== | |||
| {{welcome}} ] 01:37, 12 Mar 2005 (UTC) | |||
Latest revision as of 01:57, 27 September 2022
Unregistered editors using this IP address received messages on this talk page years ago. Since users of the IP address have likely changed, these messages have been removed. They can be viewed in the page history.