Misplaced Pages

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Babybrew6 (talk | contribs) at 18:34, 15 January 2025 (created page). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Karma Paul (1894-1984) was a Tibetan who lived in Darjeeling and accompanied six of the early British Mount Everest expeditions, as their interpreter, between the years 1922-1938. He was born as Karma Palden in Lhasa in 1894 and died in 1984.

Biography

Karma Paul was born in Lhasa, Tibet, he lost his parents at the age of twelve and was raised as an orphan by missionaries in Darjeeling.

He worked for a time in Calcutta and had been a schoolmaster in Darjeeling until he was recruited in 1922 to accompany his first expedition to Everest as an interpreter. At that time he was 28 years old and able to speak English, Tibetan, Nepali, Bengali, and various Himalayan dialects.

He was born a buddhist and raised by christian missionaries but from his 20's his religious affinities were ambiguous, "When he was Karma he was a Buddhist, and received blessings from every Lama he could get near to. When he was Paul he was a Christian" When meeting the Rongbuk Lama he was "very much of a buddhist". However, when visiting the Tibetan Mission in Darjeeling he was ostensibly a practising christian and he had 2 children who were being educated in christian schools. One of those children, Lamu Amatya, became the first Nepalese trained–nurse.

By the 1940's he was described as ‘sirdar’ and ‘a business man from Darjeeling’. He had become an entrepreneur, trained himself to be a skilled auto mechanic, and ran a taxi service in Darjeeling (although his daughter said that "he was not good at all at repairing"). He also owned a large number of racing ponies, and in the 1950s he made "a small fortune" from horse racing.

The early Everest expeditions

Karma Paul filled the role of interpreter for six of the British Everest expeditions (1922, 1924, 1933, 1935, 1936 and 1938). Each of these expeditions approached the mountain from the northern, Tibetan, side. All of the later large expeditions, between 1938 and 1952 (when Everest was successfully ascended), approached the mountain from the southern, Nepali side.

In 1921/22, before being involved with Everest, Karma Paul had taught Tibetan to Henry Morshead who worked for the Survey of India, Morshead's testimonial described Paul as “well educated and intelligent”. Morshead had been a member of the 1921 British Mount Everest reconnaissance expedition and also became a member of the 1922 British Mount Everest expedition.

General Bruce, the leader of the 1922 British Mount Everest expedition, was the first to recruit Karma Paul as interpreter. As well as speaking the various local languages he was also able to both read and write English (at one stage during the expedition Morshead was unable to write because he had frost bitten fingers and Karma Paul wrote a letter on his behalf.). In the film Climbing Mount Everest, made on the 1922 expedition by John Noel, he can be seen (at around 35-38 minutes in) dressed in similar clothes to the European expedition members, with a collar and tie and a watch-chain, acting as a go-between during the formalities between the Lama of Rongbuk Monastery and members of the British expedition.

Bruce regarded Karma Paul as “the most important subordinate member of the Expedition” although "quite new to the kind of work that he would have to do" he was "a great acquisition to the Expedition, always good company and always cheerful, full of a quaint little vanity of his own and delighted when he was praised. He served us very well indeed from one end of the Expedition to the other, and it was a great deal owing to his cheerfulness and to his excellent manners and way with the Tibetans that we never had the smallest possible misunderstanding with any officials, even of the lowest grades, to disturb our good relations with the Tibetans of any kind or class."

Everest and Nanda Devi in the 1930s

Eric Shipton had been a member of the British Everest expedition in 1933 and felt that "Our contact with the Tibetan people was made pleasant and easy by our Tibetan interpreter Karma Paul". Later, when Shipton was arranging his 1934 expedition to Nanda Devi with Bill Tilman, he sought assistance from Karma Paul: "Before leaving England I had arranged with Karma Paul to engage the services of three of the sherpas who had been with us on Everest the previous year – Angtarkay, Pasang and Kusang- and to send them down from Darjeeling to meet us in Calcutta, At Vizagapatam we sent him a wire informing him of the date of our arrival".

Then in 1935, when Shipton was the leader of the British Everest reconnaissance expedition, Karma Paul introduced him to Tenzing Norgay, that introduction gave Tenzing with his first opportunity to climb on Everest and make the first step towards his eventual success in reaching the top of Everest during the first ascent with the 1951 Everest expedition.

The 1938 British Mount Everest expedition was the last of the major British expeditions to Everest which involved Karma Paul. He was accompanied on the expedition by a servant named Pensho who "grooms and rides racing ponies in Darjeeling in ordinary life sometimes for Karma Paul". Before leaving Darjeeling the expedition leader, Bill Tilman, "was obliged to borrow a suit of Karma Paul's as my own was condemned as unsuitable for a luncheon party"

As a Darjeeling go-between

After he had taken part in a few Everest expeditions Karma Paul became a go-between in Darjeeling for a range of visitors heading into the mountains who were looking for local staff to support them. In 1933 Maurice Wilson met Karma Paul and talked with about his plans to make an illegal journey into Tibet so that he could attempt Everest alone. Although Karma Paul initially agreed to accompany him to a base camp in Tibet, "as they grew better acquainted a mutual distrust and dislike built up which finally dissolved the partnership".

Earl Denman also visited Karma Paul's office before his illicit attempt to climb Everest in 1947 and he described Karma Paul as "a heavily built man, broad and short, of more than middle age".

In 1948 the Italian orientalist Prof Giuseppi Tucci sought Karma Paul's assistance in engaging local staff when he arrived in Darjeeling at the start of one of his several expeditions into Tibet.

References

1. Driver, Felix (2015). "Intermediaries and the archive of exploration". In Konishi, Shino; Nugent, Maria; Shellam, Tiffany (eds.). Indigenous Intermediaries. Australian National University. Retrieved 14 January 2025.
2. Adams, Christine (27 September 2023). "Karma Paul and the 1922 British Himalayan Expedition". Retrieved 14 January 2025.
3. ^ Venables, Stephen (2003). Everest: Summit of Achievement. Bloomsbury Publishing PLC. p. 246. ISBN 9780747562238.
4. ^ Purandare, Nandini; Balsavar, Deepa (2024). Headstrap: Legends and Lore from the Climbing Sherpas of Darjeeling. Mountaineers Books. pp. 66–67. ISBN 978-1680516401.
5. ^ Driver, Felix; Jones, Lowri (2009). Hidden histories of exploration: Researching the RGS-IBG collections (PDF). RGS-IBG/Royal Holloway. p. 41. ISBN 978-1-905846-30-6. Retrieved 14 January 2025.
6. ^ Bruce, Charles Granville (1923). The Assault on Mount Everest 1922. Longmans. Retrieved 20 December 2024.
7. Bruce, C. G. (1922). "The Mount Everest Expedition of 1922: Darjeeling to the Rongbuk Glacier Base Camp" (PDF). Geographical Journal. 60 (6): 385–394. doi:10.2307/1781075. JSTOR 1781075. Retrieved 15 January 2025.
8. "Tibetan Mission Darjeeling" (PDF). 1936. p. 6. Retrieved 14 January 2025.
9. ^ James Ramsey, Ullman (1955). Man of Everest: the Autobiography of Tenzing. The Reprint Society. Retrieved 14 January 2025.
10. "Factsheet - Karma Paul". Royal Geographical Society. Retrieved 14 January 2025.
11. Braham, Trevor (1974). Himalayan Odyssey. Allen & Unwin. p. 39. ISBN 9780049100541.
12. Unsworth, Walter (1981). Everest. Allen Lane. ISBN 9780713911084. Retrieved 20 December 2024.
13. Bruce, Captain Geoffrey (1924). "The journey through Tibet and the establishment of the High Camps" (PDF). Geographical Journal. 64 (6): 443–450. Bibcode:1924GeogJ..64..443B. doi:10.2307/1781917. JSTOR 1781917. Retrieved 15 January 2025.
14. ^ Shipton, Eric (1944). Upon that Mountain. Hodder & Stoughton. Retrieved 14 January 2025.
15. Warren, Charles (1995). "Everest 1935: The Forgotten Adventure" (PDF). Alpine Journal. #100 (344): 3–14. ISBN 978-0948153419. ISSN 0065-6569. Retrieved 15 January 2025.
16. Ruttledge, Hugh (1937). Everest the Unfinished Adventure. Hodder & Stoughton. Retrieved 15 January 2025.
17. ^ Tilman, H. W (Bill) (1948). Everest 1938 (PDF). Cambridge University Press. p. 31. Retrieved 14 January 2025.
18. ^ Morshead, Ian (1982). The Life and Murder of Henry Morshead: A True Story of the Raj. Oleander Press. ISBN 9780900891762.
19. Noel, John (1922). "Climbing Mt. Everest: The cinematograph record of the Mount Everest Expedition of 1922". MNTNFilm. Retrieved 14 January 2025.
20. Unsworth, Walter (1981). Everest. Allen Lane. p. 241. ISBN 9780713911084. Retrieved 14 January 2025.
21. Denman, Earl (1954). Alone to Everest. Collins. pp. 140–144. Retrieved 14 January 2025.
22. James Ramsey, Ullman (1955). Tiger of the Snows: The Autobiography of Tenzing of Everest (PDF). G.P. Putnam's & Sons. p. 94. Retrieved 14 January 2025.

1. p.24
2. p.45
3. p.54
4. p.172
5. p.98
6. p.24
7. p.108
8. p.142
9. p.172
10. p.54
11. p.31
12. p.98